How Canadian MSPs Should Evaluate Payment Processors

Question 1 of 7

Can it handle the way MSPs actually bill?

Start with the billing workflow rather than the payment method.

Many MSP customers are recurring customers, but that does not necessarily mean they should be charged the same fixed amount every month.

For example, a managed services agreement might be $5,000 one month and $5,700 the next because of additional users, consumption, projects, hardware or other charges.

That makes invoice-driven automatic payments particularly valuable.

Instead of creating a separate recurring payment schedule and trying to keep it synchronized with billing, the better question is:

This reduces the number of places your team has to maintain billing information and helps keep the invoice, payment and accounting record connected.

Bottom line: The goal should be to automate payment without creating a second billing system your team has to manage.

Question 2 of 7

Does it properly support Canadian pre-authorized debits?

For Canadian MSPs, bank payments are especially important.

What is commonly called EFT in Canada can allow an MSP to collect money directly from a customer’s bank account. For recurring business payments, those withdrawals generally fall under Payments Canada’s rules for Pre-Authorized Debits, or PADs.

Variable payments deserve particular attention for MSPs. Under Rule H1, advance notice is generally required when a PAD amount varies, although the payor and payee may agree to waive or shorten applicable pre-notification requirements.

So don’t simply ask a provider whether it “supports EFT.”

The last question is easy to overlook. Saved payment information and authorization records can become deeply embedded in your monthly billing process.

Bottom line: Understanding how portable those records are before you sign up can make a future migration considerably easier.

Question 3 of 7

Does it connect payments to your PSA and accounting system?

For an MSP, the processor itself is only one piece of the workflow.

A typical stack may include:

The more manually your team has to move information between those systems, the less valuable your payment automation becomes.

Suppose an invoice starts in HaloPSA, Autotask or ConnectWise and ultimately lands in QuickBooks or Xero. Your payment system should understand the resulting invoice rather than forcing someone to recreate it.

When a customer pays, the reverse should also happen: the payment should be associated with the correct customer and invoice and reflected properly in the accounting system.

Ask vendors to demo the entire process

1. Create invoice
2. Send invoice
3. Collect payment
4. Apply payment
5. Update accounting
6. Reconcile deposit

Bottom line: A payment integration should eliminate work throughout the invoice-to-cash process, not simply provide a Pay Now button.

Question 4 of 7

What happens when a payment fails?

Successful payments are the easy part.

A better way to evaluate a payment platform is to ask what happens when something goes wrong.

A card expires. A bank account has insufficient funds. A transaction is declined. A customer replaces their credit card. An automatic payment doesn’t go through.

If every exception turns into a ticket for your accounting team, your “automated” payment process is not particularly automated.

Evaluate how the platform handles

• Expired cards
• Declined cards
• Failed bank payments
• Returned PADs
• Updated payment information
• Customer notifications
• Retry rules
• Internal alerts
• Reporting on unresolved failures

Bottom line: The objective isn’t simply a high payment success rate. It is reducing the amount of human intervention required when the happy path breaks.

Question 5 of 7

Understand the full cost, not just the advertised rate

Payment pricing can become difficult to compare because different providers divide the cost differently.

You may encounter:

For an MSP collecting large monthly invoices, the distinction between percentage-based and fixed bank-payment fees can become significant.

Consider a $10,000 invoice. Even a seemingly small percentage fee can produce a very different cost than a flat transaction fee.

Calculate your likely annual processing cost using your own payment mix rather than comparing headline rates.

Bottom line: Compare total annual cost at your real volume and payment mix, not headline rates.

Question 6 of 7

How much reconciliation work remains after the money arrives?

“Payment completed” is not the end of the workflow.

Ask the vendor to show you what your books look like after a payment.

Then ask them to show you what happens after the processor deposits a batch of payments into your bank account.

The more of that relationship the platform can preserve automatically, the less time your team spends comparing gateway reports, bank deposits and accounting entries.

This becomes even more important as transaction volume grows. A workflow that feels manageable at 50 recurring clients may become a major administrative burden at 500.

Bottom line: Ask to see your books after a single payment and after a batch deposit. The less your team reconciles by hand, the better the platform scales with you.

Question 7 of 7

Can you change processors without rebuilding your billing operation?

Payment infrastructure tends to become sticky.

Once hundreds of customers have saved cards or bank accounts, changing providers can be painful.

This is partly a payments question and partly a business-continuity question.

Bottom line: Your MSP may use the same payment platform for years. You should understand what happens both when you join and when you leave.

Payments should fit the MSP workflow, not the other way around

The right payment processor for an MSP fits the way your business already bills customers.

The total cost of getting paid includes the work that remains after the deposit, along with the fee on each transaction.

• Invoices should come from the systems your team already trusts.
• Customers should be able to authorize automatic payments securely.
• Payments should happen according to your billing rules.
• Successful transactions should flow back into accounting.
• Exceptions should be easy to identify.
• And reconciliation should require as little manual work as possible.

That is the philosophy behind Benji Pays.

Benji Pays (Live) connects payment processing with the invoice, accounting and PSA workflows MSPs already use, including invoice-driven Auto Processing and integrations with major MSP and accounting platforms.

Frequently asked questions